Look No More – Best Toys For 5 Year Old Boys Reviewed

When it comes to finding the best toys for 5 year old boys, price always seems to be an issue. It’s an age where children love gifts but they don’t always take care of them. This makes it hard to know how much to spend.

Some turn to thrift stores to try and score a diamond in the rough toy. Learn what to look for when buying second-hand toys, along with a few of the options on my list of the best toys for 5 year old boys.

Can I Buy Used Toys?

Sure! But not all of the best toys for 5 year old boys should be purchased used and those that you do choose to purchase at resale shops or garage sales should be thoroughly inspected. According to EcoLife.com, there are several benefits for buying used. Some are for your wallet while others are for the environment.

The most obvious benefit is that buying used toys will just about always cost less than buying new. As humans, we love the thrill of buying something new. But there are quite a few toys that can be purchased secondhand and perform just as well as a brand new one.

Buying used also helps the environment. When you’re the second owner of a toy, there were no new products or resources used to make it. You’re simply extending the life of the toy instead of prematurely ending it. This brings us to another environmental benefit. Toys can find themselves in landfills, wasting space and playing a part in our world’s waste problems. Because many toys are made of plastic, they simply sit and take up space.

Finally, buying used toys can have a positive effect on your family’s health. Toys made with certain materials, like paints and adhesives, can release volatile organic compounds into the air. If you purchase an older toy, there’s a higher chance that these compounds have already been released and you’ll prevent them from entering your home’s air.​

What Should I Avoid?

I love a good bargain and if I can find one of the best toys for 5 year old boys secondhand that’s in great shape, I’m game. But there are a few instances when buying used should be avoided.

Always check for lead paint. This is more common in older toys but some toy companies don’t uphold to paint standards. Also check for flaking paint.

Avoid BPA. To know if a toy contains BPA, check for the #7 plastic symbol somewhere on the toy.

Look for fatigue, especially in toys with thin, brittle plastic pieces. Look for missing pieces as well.

There are a few toys I never buy used. This includes board games (they’re always missing a piece), puzzles (same reason), and toys that I just know my kids will enjoy more if there’s no damage. To learn more about what to look or in toy safety, both used and new, check out this guide sorted by age.​

Is it wrong to want new toys?

Of course not. It’s human nature. We love the thrill of opening something up and being the first to use it and hold it. But it’s important to consider your available space and budget before purchasing a toy. Try to invest in toys rather than splurge. The included price tag doesn’t always portray the accurate value of a toy. Curious how your spending looks compared to others? According to Statista, parents spent an average of $371 in 2013 on each child. Where do you fit in?

This fun video will give you a little insight as to how parents chose to spend their toy funds.

Best Toys For 5 Year Old Boys—Top 5 Reviewed

Quality

Price

Our Rating

You won’t find anything like this in a consignment store, at least not with all the pieces. This game is a unique twist on dodgeball but without the pain and stress.

The game includes two adjustable air-mesh vests along with six soft and safe dodgeballs. It’s designed for children as young as five, and helps kids learn hand-eye coordination, timing, and how to have a blast while exercising. This game travels just about anywhere.

My kids bring it to the park where there’s plenty of room to run, throw, and dodge. If you're looking for something to get a child active, this belongs on your list of the best toys for 5 year old boys.

PROS

  • Portable
  • Safe
  • No batteries

CONS

  • Balls can be lost
  • Only for two players

Quality

Price

Our Rating

You might be able to find a toy like this used but the chances of it working as designed are slim, especially if it was sitting in a basement or garage for a while.

It’s a great educational tool for young minds. The microscope comes with pre-loaded slides for serious exploration. The microphone talks, throwing questions and fun facts out for everyone to hear. It’s the perfect first science toy for any little boy. I purchased this for my son on his fifth birthday. His sixth birthday is soon approaching and I still hear him playing with it on a regular basis.

There’s so much to learn and I love how it keeps my son interested in science and the world around him. When it comes to science toys, this is one of the best toys for 5 year old boys.

PROS

  • Educational
  • Engaging
  • Introduces kids to science

CONS

  • Requires batteries
  • Cannot be dropped

Quality

Price

Our Rating

I love interactive toys. They’re always on my list of best toys for 5 year old boys. The Crazy Forts kit comes with 69 solid plastic pieces that will allow your little one to build the fort of their dreams. Just add a bedsheet or two and you’re done.

I first saw this toy in a thrift store but it was missing nearly half the pieces. I knew that if I wanted to give my son the full experience of fort building, I needed to buy the kit new. It’s been a hit at sleepovers and I’ve really been impressed with his creativity. He seems to come up with something new every time he builds.

You won’t go wrong with a toy like this. It has all the necessary elements. It encourages creativity, promotes active play, and it’s fun!

PROS

  • Encourages creativity
  • Portable
  • No batteries

CONS

  • Pieces can be lost
  • Takes up a lot of space when assembled

Quality

Price

Our Rating

You could find one or two of these dinosaurs in a bin at a garage sale but you’ll never find the entire set, which includes twelve unique dinosaurs, all with vibrant colors and detailed features.

Let your little one set up their own Jurassic Park and have some fun and imaginative play. The dinosaurs are made from durable materials and can be used indoors and out. They’re a great learning tool and I love how they provide my little one with hours of fun, all without videos or technology of any kind. But here’s one bit of advice.

One of the benefits of buying used toys is that any offensive odors from glues or plastics have usually worn off by the time they end up in a thrift store. These toys do have an odor to them. But just let them sit out of their packaging for a few days and you’ll be good to go.

PROS

  • Detailed designs
  • Large set
  • Doesn’t require batteries

CONS

  • Strong smell
  • Smaller, easy to misplace

Quality

Price

Our Rating

While you’re sure to find a basic robot toy at a used toy store, you’ll never find a remote-control robot with all the pieces. This robot does everything. He shoots missiles, walks, talks, and dances. He’s also over two feet tall, making it a really impressive gift that won’t put you over budget.

It does require six AA batteries, which is more than a lot of toys, but this robot does a whole lot more than most other toys. Remote control toys are always more fun and this robot doesn’t disappoint. I bought this robot for my nephew. We had a blast setting up toys on the coffee table and having the robot shoot them off.

It’s one of those memories I’ll never forget and I got to feel like a kid for a bit. It’s hands down one of the best toys for 5 year old boys.

PROS

  • Remote controlled
  • Ten functions
  • Large

CONS

  • Small missiles can be lost
  • Requires several batteries

So which is my favorite toy to buy new? When it comes to the best toys for 5 year old boys, the winner has to be the Crazy Forts kit. I haven’t come across many other toys that don’t require batteries or electricity that have provided my son and his friends with so many hours of fun. If you can find the kit in a thrift store, that’s great. But to ensure that you’ll get the full fort-building experience, let your kid be the first owner of this kit before you pass it on to someone else.